Licensed Plumber LICENSE #CO88900054
Call For a Licensed Plumber: (317) 859-9999

Looking for a plumber to assist with your hot water heater repair, sump pump maintenance, or other plumbing needs? There are a number of outstanding plumbers in Greenwood, Indiana, and in the greater Indianapolis area. In fact, some homeowners may find it difficult to narrow their list to just one or two trusted plumbers.

In this article, we’ll highlight a few of the top plumbers in Indianapolis, Greenwood, and beyond. We hope this guide will be useful to you as you seek plumbing professionals who do excellent work, offer you outstanding customer service, and ensure honest upfront pricing.

How We Ranked the Top Plumbers in Greenwood

In assessing some of the top Greenwood and Indianapolis IN plumbers, we used a few criteria. Specifically, we considered the following items:

  • We looked carefully at consumer reviews and testimonials, specifically those posted to Yelp, Facebook, and Google. We consider this to be one of the best ways to determine overall customer satisfaction.
  • We also confirmed the plumbers we selected are all properly licensed and insured. And, we verified their standing with the Better Business Bureau.
  • We’ve tried to focus on family-owned companies with local connections to the Greenwood area… not big, nationwide chains or conglomerates.
  • Additionally, we considered the number of services offered by each plumber, including expertise with sump pumps, water heaters, emergency plumbing services, and beyond.

Based on these ranking factors, we’ve developed a list of 10 plumbing companies that we’re happy to recommend to residents of Greenwood. In the following list, we’ll tell you more about each of these plumbing services, their history, and their reputation in Greenwood, Indiana.

Ranking the 10 Best Plumbers in Greenwood and Indianapolis

Carter's My Plumber Logo

1) Carter’s My Plumber

There are a number of reasons why we consider Carter’s My Plumber to be the cream of the crop as far as local plumbing services go and are picked as best plumbers in Greenwood Indiana. Look at a few of the company’s primary selling points:

Carter's My Plumber Team
Carter’s My Plumber Team
  • Carter’s My Plumber is fully licensed, and in fact posts their license number at the top of their site, making it very easy to find and verify.
  • The company is a family-owned Greenwood institution. Currently, three generations of Carters work for the company, representing more than 100 years of combined plumbing experience.
  • The locally-owned plumbing company extends their services to home and business owners throughout the Indianapolis metropolitan area.
  • The company promises fair, up-front pricing, with no big surprises when the invoice arrives.
  • Their services have won widespread customer satisfaction and approval, making them one of the best-loved plumbing maintenance and repair services in the general area.
  • It should also be noted that their two dogs, Bella and Max, are the best plumbing mascots in the region!
Max Bella
Bella and Max, Carter’s My Plumber Mascots

The bottom line: Next time you have plumbing needs that arise, we recommend calling Carter’s to learn more about their services. You can visit their Greenwood Indiana plumbers page for additional information about pricing, services, COVID 19 precautions, etc.

2) Johnson Comfort

Johnson Comfort offers a range of home services that include heating and cooling work, but most importantly, plumbing expertise. They have much to recommend them for, and we’re happy to have them at #2 on our list of local plumbing repair services. Here are a few reasons why we’re pleased to endorse this Greenwood and Indianapolis plumber:

  • The company has won many local awards and accolades for friendly service and for plumbing expertise.
  • They offer around-the-clock emergency services, making them a good local plumber to call for any urgent hot water heater or sump pump needs.
  • Johnson Comfort also boasts clear, up-front pricing without any big surprises come billing time.
  • They’ve been a reliable Indianapolis IN plumber for 50 years and counting, and have more than earned their reputation as a trustworthy local plumbing service.

To learn more about the services offered by Johnson Comfort, check out their business website.

3) Winters Plumbing

Another Greenwood home service company that we can highly recommend is Winters. Here’s what local homeowners and business owners should know before they hire Winters for their services.

  • Winters boasts a range of basic services that include sump pump, hot water heater, and other plumbing work. But they also offer gas line repair, drain repair, and so much more.
  • They are a small business with ample expertise in the Greenwood, Indiana area. Their reputation in the community is top-notch.
  • They offer a full customer satisfaction guarantee for all their services.
  • Their services have won excellent reviews across the board, including raves on Google and Yelp.

For more details about Winters Plumbing, check out their home page.

4) Earl Gray Plumbing

Earl Gray is another Indiana stalwart. There’s plenty to like about them, including the following:

  • Earl Gray & Sons has accumulated more than 60 years of service in the Greenwood area. They enjoy a sterling reputation among local home and business owners.
  • They are experts in hot water heater repair, water softener installation, preventative and routine plumbing maintenance, and more.
  • The company provides their services on an emergency basis; call them 24-7 to address urgent issues with water heaters, etc.

For additional insight into Earl Gray, including details about their COVID 19 precautions, check out their website.

5) Allen Plumbing

Allen provides emergency and routine services in Indianapolis and throughout the surrounding area. A few quick bullet points about their services include:

  • They are available 24/7.
  • They handle sump pump maintenance, drain cleaning, kitchen and bathroom services, water softeners, and more.
  • They receive excellent customer reviews from Greenwood homeowners, and enjoy an outstanding reputation throughout Indiana.

These are just a few of the reasons why we’re happy to include Allen on our list of local plumber services. For more insight into what sets them apart, we encourage you to check out their website at your next opportunity to do so.

6) P & K Plumbing

P & K is a local home service company with more than 25 years of experience and an exemplary reputation in the community. Here are a few additional reasons why we recommend the P & K team:

  • They are fully licensed and insured, and you can find their license number right on their home page.
  • They offer a full-service plumbing menu, including toilet repair, pipe repair, sump pump repair, hot water heater maintenance, and more.
  • They have a ton of great reviews that speak to their professionalism, the quality of their work, and the friendliness of their service to local home and business owners.

Want to learn more about P&K? You can check them out on their company website.

7) Grateful Plumber

Grateful Plumber provides high-level expertise and friendly service to their customers in Greenwood and beyond. Consider a handful of reasons to seek the services of Grateful.

  • They have excellent reviews from local homeowners, including raves for their friendly and personable service.
  • They offer a range of services, including not just residential services, but also commercial services.
  • They have won a ton of awards and accolades for their excellent workmanship.

There’s a lot to love about Grateful Plumber. Learn more about their services by visiting their site.

8) Indy Jones Plumbing

Now, let’s take a look at the services offered by Indy Jones Plumbing, another Indiana institution.

  • These plumbers are fully licensed and insured, and you can find more information about their licensure on the front page of their website.
  • They have been active in central Indiana for two decades and counting.
  • They guarantee satisfaction in all of their services, and they offer full, transparent, up-front pricing on everything that they do.

Don’t sleep on Indy Jones, a really reputable local plumbing service. Head to their website for additional information about their services in the Greenwood zip code and beyond.

9) Peterman HVAC

What about Peterman HVAC? While they clearly provide some services in heating and cooling, Peterman also does work with drains, hot water heaters, and more. Some additional points about their work:

  • The Peterman team offers 24/7 emergency services.
  • They promise 100 percent customer satisfaction for all their heating, cooling, and plumbing work.
  • Their services all come with transparent, no-surprise pricing.

This company has earned the trust of countless homeowners and business owners in Central Indiana. To find out more about their services, call the phone number posted on their website.

10) Complete Comfort

There’s a lot to appreciate about Complete Comfort, the last business on our list, so don’t overlook them just because they fall at the bottom. In fact, Complete Comfort can boast about all of the following:

  • Their services encompass not just plumbing maintenance, but also plumbing work.
  • Their technicians are available 24/7, making them available in the case of an emergency.
  • They are a BBB and EPA certified team.

You can learn a lot more about Complete Comfort either by calling their phone number or by visiting their business website.

More Tips for Choosing a Greenwood, Indiana Plumber

Carter’s My Plumber Truck

We hope this guide has been helpful to you as you look for a good, dependable plumbing repair company. If you have additional questions about picking a good plumber, we can offer just a few words of advice.

  • It’s okay to get multiple quotes. If you have an emergency need, then you have an emergency need. But if you have the luxury of time, it never hurts to call two or three different companies to compare quotes. This can help you make a fully-informed decision about the plumbing repair services you choose.
  • Take reviews seriously. A company like Carter’s My Plumber, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 on Google, can be relied on for friendly, attentive service… period. While these reviews are not necessarily infallible, they can give you a really good sense of general customer satisfaction levels.
  • Ask around. Another good tip is to ask your local friends and family members if they have any personal recommendations. Have they recently hired local plumber services? And if so, do they recommend the company they chose? These direct recommendations can often be really impactful.
  • Remember to confirm the license number. A valid Indiana plumbing license shows that the company you’re working with is legitimate, and can generally be depended on for quality, professionalism, and fair pricing. Additionally, if something goes wrong with the service, you’ll have clear recourse. This isn’t always the case if you choose unlicensed services.
  • Don’t forget about COVID 19. This is partly a joke; who among us could possibly forget about COVID 19? But in all seriousness, as you interview plumbing companies, it never hurts to ask about the steps they’ll take to keep you, your family, and your technician safe from COVID exposure. If you’re not comfortable with the answer you receive, that’s reason enough to keep searching for alternative services.

These are just a few pointers that may give you clarity and confidence as you investigate plumbing companies in Greenwood and the broader Indianapolis area.

Final Thoughts on Selecting a Plumbing Pro

If you have questions about a specific service or company, use the phone number on their website and reach out to them directly. And remember, if you’re not totally comfortable with the way in which they address your concerns, that’s reason enough to keep looking. Good luck as you search for a dependable local plumber in the Greenwood area!

Kelson Carter

Article reviewed by:

Kelson Carter, aka, The Prince of Plumbing

Kelson is a 3rd generation Plumbing Contractor. His family business is located in Greenwood, Indiana, and provides Residential Plumbing Service to the Indianapolis Metro market.

Kelson grew up watching his grandfather and father do plumbing. After graduating high school, Kelson went to Trade School and became a Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor. He is also Certified in Backflow Prevention. He currently owns and operates Carter's My Plumber with his parents.


Schedule Your Appointment Now

  • Date Format: MM slash DD slash YYYY
Five Star Review Monday!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay! 317-859-9999 /
Trying out Portrait Mode on this Great Fall Day!🍂🍁
317-859-9999 /
Five Star Review!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!” 317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
Five Star Review!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
Any Friends Fans out there?
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
Looking for a change in your career path? Need more opportunity? We've got the team for you!
What a Beauty!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!” 317-859-9999 /
Carter’s My Plumber will be giving away a FREE Pumpkin for EVERY Water Heater we replace in the month of October! 

“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
Five Star Review Monday!
Golden Friday! ☀️
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
Five Star Review!
317-859-9999 /
Carter's My Plumber Logo

Get your home tips here

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!