Call For a Licensed Plumber: (317) 859-9999

Tub / Shower Replacement

Tub Replacement Carter's My Plumber

Do You need to Replace Tub or Shower?

If you need to replace Tub or Shower in your home, you’ve come to the right place!  Carter’s My Plumber specializes in tub and shower replacements!  We are focused on doing the best job possible for our customers.  It’s important to replace tub or shower with a high quality in mind, along with all options available.

Here is what customers have said about our work:

Here is what customers have said about our work:

FAST – We can Remove your old shower and replace it in just one day!
Aging Bathtubs can be an eyesore

Aging Bathtubs can be an eyesore

Aging Bathtubs can be an eyesore, a can have safety risks, can make your house look out of date, and misses out on the efficiencies of a new Tub or Shower unit. At Carter’s we will customize a new Tub or new Shower Replacement/Conversion solution that fits within your budget and the need of your home.

Carter’s My Plumber is a Licensed Plumbing Company

Carter’s My Plumber is a Licensed Plumbing Company

Carter’s My Plumber is a Licensed Plumbing Company specializing in Bathtub and Shower Replacements. We have a team of experts who are trained to remove an old tub or shower and replace it with a new one. We ensure our workmanship is superb, and it comes with a guarantee. The new unit will fit tightly and securely where the old unit has been removed, and all in ONE DAY!


We can supply accurate cost estimates usually within hours of calling us. To talk to a bathtub expert, Call Us: (317) 859-9999.
Or Get an Estimate Online:

Tub or Shower Solutions

Here is some detailed information of various Tub or Shower solutions we’ve delivered to hundreds of customers over the years:

bathtub replacement indianapolis, in

Replace Tub

There’s an assumption that bathrooms are supposed to have baths!  Traditionally speaking most homes have at least one tub.  This helps with resale value.  Although, we are seeing more and more homeowner’s convert their tubs to showers.

Baths are extremely relaxing!  Nohting better than coming home for a hard day’s work and taking a nice warm bath.  Plus, there is always the option of adding bath salts for sore muscles.

Baths are better for the family!  Baths are fun for kids as they see it as playtime.  Small children don’t enjoy a shower on their head, so it is best to use a tub while the kids are younger.

Not having a tub may make it harder to sell your home.  Some families will not consider a home without a tub.  The aging population may prefer a tub over a shower as well.

Tubs can be replaced with beatufiul surrounds that seal tightly to the tub unit itself.  They have additional shelf space and they are easy to clean.

Replace Shower

As many people are converting tubs to showers in order to get more space in their bathroom.

Free up space by replacing the tub with a shower unit.  Showers give you the benefit of being able to fit in special places, like corners.

There is more variety with shower units.  There are shower enclosures with pivot, inline, sliding and more shower doors.  There are also walk-in showers that make accessibility very easy.

Modern showers have about every option possible.  There are different types of water pressures, built-in radios, and even showers where the water can change color!

Quick – showers are super fast!  Much easier than running a tub of water.  A quick shower gives you a burst of energy, especially in the morning.

Water saver!  Showers use less water than filling up a tub as long as the shower time is not over extended.

Tub to Shower Conversion

Change the Tub to a Shower

It is easier to change a tub to a shower than a shower to tub  In order to get the proper shower expierence, it is best to utilize the entire space.  Plus, additional faucets can be added.

Remove the old Tub: This involves removing the plumbing, and carefully taking the old tub out.  Walls and flooring can be involved.  It’s important to plan for the proper removal of the old tub and cleaning up the mess as you go is another essential step.

Install the Shower Pan: The shower pan is the most important part of a new walk-in shower, and typically a custom, concrete-set pan will be poured. Proper care must be taken to achieve adequate slope of the pan to the drain. The biggest concern is waterproofing the shower pan. Grout joints between the tiles on the shower floor are not waterproofed and water will eventually seep through, into the shower pan and down into the room below. A seamless waterproof membrane must be installed either on top of, or beneath the concrete-set shower pan.

Install Wallboard: In many bathrooms, the three walls surrounding a tub are painted drywall. This drywall must be removed and replaced with Durrock, or another brand of tile backer board to prevent water saturation. Many contractors will use mold-resistant drywall as the substrate behind the tile, but over time seeping water will cause the wallboard to deteriorate.Tile must be installed along the three shower walls and on the shower pan. Large or small tile formats can be used for the shower walls and a mosaic (or small format) tile should be used at the shower floor to conform to the contour of the pan. The joints between all tiles will need to be grouted, and then sealed.

Obviously, there are other steps involved a bathtub to shower remodel, but overall it can a relatively straight forward renovation that can completely transform the look and function of any bathroom.

Shower Fiberglass

Fiberglass Tub

Homeowners on a tight budget can choose a fiberglass tub and shower combination unit for an economical option to replace a current tub. Fiberglass is lightweight and relatively inexpensive, with a nice appearance. Homeowners can choose a tub and shower unit with shelves on the shower walls for holding soaps, shampoos and other items and towel bars are another popular addition to provide added convenience. Fiberglass remains the material of choice for tub and shower replacement when saving money is an important factor.

Why Do People Recommend Us?

Here are just a few reasons people call us for all Tub or Shower Replacement Projects:

Free, In-Home Estimates

Free, In-Home Estimates

We know you want a great deal, and we’re happy to prove we’ll give you one. Whether it be a tub surround unit or or a complete bathroom remodel, we always offer accurate and no hassle estimates that include every aspect of your project…so there are never any surprises.

FAST – One Day Installation

FAST – One Day Installation

Your home is unique and all your own and your bathroom tub shouldn’t be any different. Whether recommending an affordable replacement or a 100% customized design solution, we’ve got bathroom designers and product experts ready to give you a perfect solution.

Clean & Neat in a Customer’s Home

Clean & Neat in a Customer’s Home

How your tub unit and fixtures are installed is equally important to which unit or remodel solution you choose. Our certified installers make sure every single water line, drain and tub accessory is expertly installed to provide years and years of enjoyment with your new bathtub unit.

Family Plumber

Your 100% Happiness Guarantee!

We haven’t stayed in business for over 37 years by mediocre work. We are a locally owned family business that prides itself on delighting customers just like you from the moment you call until your job is completely finished to your satisfaction. From our family to yours, your complete satisfaction is our #1 priority.

Plumbing Reviewer

Eugene Bennett

Carter's My Plumber
5 out of 5 with 103 ratings

The Carter plumber was very professional – suggested additional back-up, gave estimates and did job quickly & well.


We can supply accurate cost estimates usually within hours of calling us. To talk to a bathtub expert, call Us: (317) 859-9999

Or Get a Estimate Online!