Licensed Plumber LICENSE #CO88900054
Call For a Licensed Plumber: (317) 859-9999
Tankless water heaters are getting a lot of attention and are growing popular for their energy efficiency, smarter size, and longevity.

However, homeowners whose water supply comes from a well rather than municipal pipes are having a hard time deciding if a tankless water heater will do the right job. Why? Because they believe that tankless heaters don’t work with well water.

Knowing Your Water

Before we get into the details as to whether tankless water heaters work with well water or not, let’s break down a few crucial factors about water.

The type of water you get, whether it’s from a municipal supply or a well, determines tankless water heater performance.

How To Know What Water You Are On

Hard water can be a major issue for plumbing and drainage pipes, and the same rule applies to water heaters. Finding out if you have hard water at home involves testing which you can either DIY or call in a professional to do, so you get accurate values.

DIY Water Hardness Test

A quick way to test water hardness at home is to check your water’s reactivity with soap. A defining feature of hard water is that it renders soap ineffective by keeping it from making enough suds to wash out the grease.

Use a clear bottle or container with a lid or cap, and fill it with a measured 12 ounces of water. Measuring it helps keep the test results objective and standard. You’ll need some soap for this test, so choose simple ingredient types like liquid castile soap, which doesn’t have many chemicals that will react with water.

Start by adding ten drops of liquid castile soap to the bottle or container of water, and shake it until the soap mixes with water.

Open the container and check the surface for bubbles and suds. If you can see lots of bubbles, it means that the water is soft. If you can see very few bubbles, it means that the water is hard, and if it takes a lot of drops of soaps to finally produce more bubbles, it shows that the water is very hard.

Professional Water Hardness Test

You can also call us in to perform an accurate water hardness test that determines the specific hardness level. Based on the results, you can determine whether your water system needs a softener because hard water can leave behind a scale that damages pipes and will impact heater efficacy, which means having to replace it.

Well Water vs. City Water

Well, water is actually very different when compared to city water. There are plenty of benefits of drinking well water, because it contains healthy minerals, while city water is treated with certain chemicals for being taken from heavily polluted lakes and streams.

However, well water is also generally hard, which can have a negative effect on everything that comes into contact with it, like laundry, pipes, your skin and hair, and even glass. Another problem is that wells have lower water pressure.

Tankless Water Heater Performance

Let’s evaluate tankless water heaters’ performance and compatibility with well water.

With Well Water

It’s a myth that tankless water heaters don’t work with well water, but let’s discuss people’s reasons for thinking so. The first reason is that well water generally runs colder than city water, so tankless water heaters wouldn’t be efficient.

Secondly, water pressure in wells is low, which can affect the performance of a water heater that depends on consistent water pressure. Lastly, well water has higher hardness levels, but this factor can negatively impact heating systems with tanks. Not to mention, it’s can be addressed easily by calling us in to install water softeners.

With City Water

Water from the municipal supply in most cities is predominantly soft, which allows better washing, less use of soap, and healthy plumbing. Since soft water will leave fewer mineral deposits when water is heated, tankless water heating systems need to be cleaned out less frequently than if they were heating hard water.

Will Well Water Heat Up As Fast As I Need?

Coming to the issue of whether a tankless water heater can deliver enough hot water to your faucets in time, there are a few solutions to the problem. Homeowners who complain that using a tankless water heater with a well doesn’t give them enough hot water or hot water at all, are clearly facing the issue of a small heater.

Although well water generally runs colder, the concern can be resolved easily by opting for a tankless water heater with bigger capacity. In fact, in winter, using a tankless water heater with well water can give hotter water than if you used the city water supply.

City water supply pipes run just below the surface, which makes temperatures almost freezing, while the water in wells stays warmer. When it comes to issues about water pressure, you can install a water pressure regulator to make heating cycles more efficient.

Best Water Heater Option

Well water, due to its low pressure and hardness levels, can create the same problems for water heating systems with tanks as well. Combine that with the low average lifespan of a water heater with a tank, and you may be losing money in the long run.

Comparatively, tankless water heaters still remain a budget-friendly and convenient option for well water users. Although initial installation costs are higher, they can generally last longer with regular maintenance and consistent water treatment.

Just remember to carefully assess your water needs and opt for a tankless water heater with a bigger capacity so ensure a steady supply of hot water.

Is It Difficult Getting Well Water?

Considering the health benefits of using hard water, many homeowners want to make the shift from a city water supply to private wells. Mainly, three types of wells are used, namely dug, driven, and drilled wells.

You’ll have to call in a company to drill the hole and a professional well pump installer as well. Of course, your private well plan should comply with local regulations. The driller you hire to construct the well should obtain a well drilling permit before doing so.

It’s also best that you have the septic tank installed before drilling a well so that it can be drilled at least 75 feet away from it.

After installation, your private well needs to undergo a series of tests for the chlorination and disinfection process.  Here at Carter’s, we can help connect your home to new water lines.

Is Getting A New Water System Expensive?

Installing a private well on your property will have higher initial costs, after which you no longer have to worry about monthly water bills. According to HomeAdvisor, drilling a private well that’s 150 feet-deep can cost around $5,500. Based on the depth, the cost of a project can range anywhere from $1,500 to $12,000.

So yes, it will be expensive at first, but a properly-drilled well can last a long time, during which you don’t have to rely on the municipal water supply.

Don’t Settle for Less – Get a Tankless Water Heating System

Don’t settle for a water heater with a tank just because you’re worried that a tankless water heater can’t get the job done. Getting the right size, opting for regular maintenance, and investing in high-quality components can ensure convenience and savings in the long run.

You can call in one of the expert plumbers here at Carter’s to understand more about installing a tankless water heater for well water. The water heater installation doesn’t take very long and you can get hot water in the same day. With our experience, you’ll get reliable installation services and a heater that’s properly-sized to suit your needs.

Kelson Carter

Article reviewed by:

Kelson Carter, aka, The Prince of Plumbing

Kelson is a 3rd generation Plumbing Contractor. His family business is located in Greenwood, Indiana, and provides Residential Plumbing Service to the Indianapolis Metro market.

Kelson grew up watching his grandfather and father do plumbing. After graduating high school, Kelson went to Trade School and became a Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor. He is also Certified in Backflow Prevention. He currently owns and operates Carter's My Plumber with his parents.


Instagram

Schedule Your Appointment Now

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

Happy Work Anniversary, Wes! 🔧💪👑

When it comes to getting the job done right, Wes is the one you want on your side. His skill, work ethic, and positive attitude make a difference on every job and for every customer he serves.

We’re lucky to have such an awesome technician on our team — someone who truly takes pride in his work and represents what we’re all about.

Cheers to another great year, Wes! Thanks for all you do! 
📱 317-859-9999
Happy Work Anniversary, Chris! 🎉

From the first call to the last follow-up, you’re the friendly voice our customers can count on every day. Your patience, positivity, and dedication don’t go unnoticed — you help keep everything running smoothly behind the scenes. Thanks for all you do!

We’re so grateful to have you on our team and appreciate all the care you put into your work. Here’s to another great year ahead! 👏

📱 317-859-9999
The Carter crew: 90s edition 📼
Happy Work Anniversary to one of our apprentice plumbers, Alex! 👑

Alex has been putting in the time, effort, and heart it takes to grow in this industry. He shows up ready to learn and support the team every single day. We’re thankful for him and proud to have him as part of our work family. 

Thanks for all you do, Alex! Let's give him a congrats! 💦🛠💪
📱317-859-9999
Happy Work Anniversary to one of our licensed plumbers, Josh! 💪

From tackling tough repairs to making sure every job is done right the first time, Josh brings skill, dedication, and a great attitude to everything he does. Having a licensed pro like him on the team means our customers can trust they’re in good hands every step of the way.

We’re proud to have you on the team, Josh—thanks for all you do! 💧
📱 317-859-9999
At our company, it’s more than plumbing—it’s family.

Today we had our youngest team member checking out the company truck. It may be a few years before the service calls start, but it’s never too early to learn the family business. 🚚🔧
 
📱 317-859-9999
Happy 4 Year Work Anniversary to one of our apprentice plumbers, Peyton! 👑

Over the last four years, Peyton has grown into a dependable, hard-working part of our team. His commitment to learning the trade and showing up every day with a great attitude does not go unnoticed. We’re proud to have him and excited to see what the future holds. 👏🔧

If Peyton is in your home this week, give him a big congrats! 
317-859-9999
Brighter days are coming—and so are fewer frozen pipes. ☀️💧

Warmer weather is right around the corner, and we’re ready for whatever this season brings. Call us to get ready for the warmer temps that will be here SOON enough! 317-859-9999
Have you heard about our CARTER CARES program? 

Check us out online at www.cartersmyplumber.com to learn more about our water heater giveaway program. 

In short, we install a completely FREE water heater to someone in our community in need. We'd love to help you get HOT water! 💦
Sweat practice isn’t just a workout—it’s a skill. 💪🔥

In plumbing, properly sweating copper pipe means strong, leak-free connections that last. It takes patience, precision, and a whole lot of practice—but it’s worth it every time.

Call the professionals- 317-859-9999
Happy Work Anniversary to our apprentice plumber, Peyton! 🛠💦👑

From day one, Peyton has jumped in ready to learn and put in the work. Peyton has shown a strong work ethic, a willingness to expand his skill set, and shown up each day with a great attitude on the job.

If Peyton is in your home this week, give him a big CONGRATS! He deserves it! 317-859-9999 💪
Happy Work Anniversary to our comfort advisor, Joedy! 👑

His knowledge, professionalism, and genuine care for our customers don’t go unnoticed. He's an essential part of our team, has been for YEARS, and we're grateful for all he does! 

Thank you for being a trusted advisor and always making our customers feel confident and cared for. Here’s to another great year! Let's give him a big congrats! 🛠💦💪
Hands-on learning is the heart of the trades. 🛠️ 

Our technicians gain experience in the field every day, building skills that last a lifetime. Thankful for the trades & thankful for our team! 

Call 317-859-9999 to get a well-trained craftsman in YOUR home.
Happy Work Anniversary to one of our Plumbers, Brandon! 🔧💦 

Thanks for showing up every day ready to serve our customers with skill and a great attitude. Your hard work and craftsmanship are an essential part of our team. We appreciate all you do!

If Brandon is in your home this week, give him a congrats! He deserves it! 317-859-9999
Plumbing meets precision. 🔥

Welding helps create strong, secure connections where it matters most. Give us a call and have the professionals take care of the problem! 317-859-9999
Due to today’s snow, our office is moving appointments to keep our team safe. Emergency calls will still be monitored. We will be back at it tomorrow! 

Thank you for your understanding—stay safe and warm! ❄️
317-859-9999
Carter's My Plumber- we've been doing this for a LONG, long time! 💦

317-859-9999
Happy 3-Year Work Anniversary to one of our rock star customer service representatives, Erin! 💪

For the past three years, Erin has been one of the friendly voices our customers count on every day. Her kindness, professionalism, and dedication help set the tone for the Carter Plumbing experience. We’re so grateful to have you on our team, Erin—thank you for all you do! 👑

317-859-9999
Folder highlights JavaScript tracks traffic source/medium via cookies, sending form data from Gravity Forms submissions to reports.funnelboostmedia.net.