Water Heater Repair & Installation Indianapolis | Carter's My Plumber
Hot Water Today, or It's You We Pay!™
Carter's My PlumberSince 1969
Carter's technician installing a new water heater

Water Heater Repair & Installation in Indianapolis

No hot water, a leaking tank or a heater that is past its prime: Carter's has fixed and replaced water heaters across Indianapolis and Greenwood since 1969. Same-day service, a 2-hour arrival window and your price before we start.

"Wesley Bash installed my new water heater the same day I called. He was professional, prompt and courteous!! Rare qualities these days!! Thanks!"

Ruth Hein, Indianapolis · Google review

Rated 4.9 by Thousands of Indy Homeowners

Google
Rated 4.9 based on5,023 Google Reviews
Angi
Rated 4.8 based on55 Angi Reviews
Better Business Bureau
Accredited BusinessA+ Rating
Facebook
98% Recommend322 Facebook Reviews
Licensed Plumbing Contractor #CO88900054 PHCC Company of the Year 2022 Bonded & insured Three generations, family owned
Carter's technician finishing a tankless water heater install

Hot Water Today, or It's You We Pay

Tank, tankless, gas or electric. One licensed plumber handles the repair or the full replacement, start to finish, and you approve the price before any work begins. Call by 3 PM and we will have your water heater installed the same day, or we pay you $500. The guarantee excludes special-order units, commercial units, and any work outside our standard residential scope.

  • Same-day water heater repair
  • Tank and tankless replacement
  • Gas and electric units
  • Bradford White and Navien installs
  • Expansion tanks, valves and venting to code
  • Haul-away of the old unit

Signs Your Water Heater Is Failing

Catch it early and a repair is often enough. Wait, and you are looking at a flooded utility room.

1No hot water, or it runs out fastA failed element, thermostat or burner, or sediment eating up tank space.
2Rumbling or popping soundsSediment baked onto the bottom of the tank. Flushing helps early; a noisy old tank is on its way out.
3Rusty or cloudy hot waterCorrosion inside the tank or a spent anode rod. Rust in the hot side only points to the heater.
4Water around the baseA slow leak from a fitting can be fixed. A leaking tank cannot, and it will not get better.
5Pilot light keeps going outThermocouple, gas valve or venting trouble. Worth a same-day look, especially on gas units.
6It is 10 years old or moreMost tanks last 8 to 12 years. Past that, repairs cost more than they are worth.

What a New Water Heater Costs in Indianapolis

Two homes can need very different jobs, so we show a range, not one number. These are what Indianapolis homeowners paid Carter's over the last 12 months, installed.

$2,200 – $6,500Typical installed range, tank or tankless
FreeReplacement estimates, in your home
$79Repair diagnostic, credited to the repair

Not a quote. Your tech confirms the exact price on site, before any work starts. No interest if paid in full in 12 months with approved credit.

Carter's team member at the office taking a call

How It Works

Four quick steps, no surprises.

  1. 1 Book Online or by phone, 24/7. Pick a 2-hour window and our team confirms it.
  2. 2 We arrive on time We text when we are on the way. Late? $50 off the job.
  3. 3 Price before work Your tech explains the options. You approve the price first.
  4. 4 Fixed and cleaned up Shoe covers on, mess gone, job guaranteed.

Repair It or Replace It?

Our tech will tell you straight. Here is the rule of thumb we use.

Usually worth repairing
  • Under 8 years old and the tank is sound
  • Failed element, thermostat, thermocouple or gas valve
  • Leak at a fitting, valve or the T&P line, not the tank
  • Pilot or ignition trouble
  • Sediment noise on a younger tank (a flush fixes it)
Book a $79 Diagnostic
Time to replace
  • Water leaking from the tank itself
  • 10 years old or more, especially with rust in the hot water
  • Repair cost is more than half the price of a new unit
  • Second major repair in two years
  • You want lower bills or endless hot water (tankless)
See Replacement Pricing

What Indy Homeowners Say About Our Water Heater Work

Real reviews from Indianapolis and Greenwood families.

A
Audrey SchaferCarmel · Aug 2026
Google review
★★★★★

"We called Carter's for a second opinion after a bad experience with a different plumbing company. They came out the next day. Nice, thorough, and HONEST!"

Tech: Mike R. · Main line diagnosis View on Google →
R
Ruth HeinIndianapolis · Sept 2026
Google review
★★★★★

"Wesley Bash installed my new water heater the same day I called. He was professional, prompt and courteous!! Rare qualities these days!! Thanks!"

Tech: Wesley Bash · Same-day water heater View on Google →
W
Wayne JuddGreenwood · Sept 2026
Google review
★★★★★

"Brad and Jared were on time and were professional and cleaned up after the water heater replacement. From the first call to the finished job was about three hours."

Techs: Brad & Jared · Water heater replacement View on Google →
Read more reviews on Google →
Current Plumbing SpecialsSave on the services your home needs most. Mention the coupon when you book.
$50 OFFAny Plumbing Service $300 OFFSerenity Series Sump Pump Battery Backup $500 OFFBradford White Allegiant® Water Heater View AllCoupons →

On every Carter's visit:Family owned since 1969|2-hour arrival window|Up-front pricing|Hot Water Today, or it's you we pay

Get Service Now

Water Heater Service Across Greater Indianapolis

We serve these communities and more, from the office nearest you:

Map of the Greater Indianapolis service area
Hover a City Pick a community to see your nearest Carter's office.

Not sure if you are in our range? Call (317) 859-9999 and we will let you know.

Offices in North Indianapolis, Downtown Indianapolis and Greenwood

Water Heater Questions, Answered

Most replacements inside Indianapolis and Greenwood happen the same day you call. We carry common 40 and 50 gallon tanks on the truck. Tankless and specialty units are usually next day.

Still have a question? Call (317) 859-9999, any time, day or night.

Carter's My Plumber

Family-owned Indianapolis plumbers since 1969. Three generations of the Carter family, still answering for every job.

Offices

North Indianapolis
450 E 96th St, Ste 500
Indianapolis, IN 46240

Downtown Indianapolis
55 S State Ave, Ste 141
Indianapolis, IN 46201

Greenwood
886 N State Rd 135, Ste A
Greenwood, IN 46142

Contact

Hours

Calls answered and booked 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
Service Monday through Friday, with after-hours availability
Book online any time

2-Hour Arrival Window

Late for your window? We take $50 off the job.

Indiana Licensed Plumbing Contractor License #CO88900054 Licensed Well Pump Installer License #4333PI Registered Cross-Connection Control (Backflow) Inspector Registration #BF13-4953 Family Owned Since 1969 PHCC Company of the Year 2022 BBB A+ Rating Licensed, Bonded & Insured

Carter's My Plumber provides water heater, drain, sewer and plumbing service throughout Greater Indianapolis

© 2026 Carter's My Plumber. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy Terms of Service Careers