Licensed Plumber LICENSE #CO88900054
Call For a Licensed Plumber: (317) 859-9999

Is your water heater on its last legs? If your unit has been in place for more than 12-15 years, you may be almost ready for a new one. And as you think about getting a new water heater, there are a few basic decisions you’ll need to make. One of the most fundamental decisions is whether to spring for a tankless water heater.

Basically, there are two options when it comes to hot water heaters. The traditional tank type heats many gallons of water and then holds them in supply, ready for use whenever you need it. Tankless units heat your water on demand; true to their name, they don’t have a supply tank.

So which option makes the most sense for you and your family? When thinking about getting a tankless unit versus a more conventional one, there are a number of pros and cons to consider.

Adjustable water heater
Adjustable water heater

The Pros of Getting a Tankless Water Heater

Let’s start with the positives. What are some of the primary reasons to consider getting a tankless water heater? Some of the advantages include:

  • A tankless water heater will be more energy efficient: Tankless water heaters work entirely on demand. What this means is that your unit will only heat water when you run the shower or turn on the faucet. By contrast, a tank unit requires ongoing heating throughout the day. The upshot: A tankless water heater can help you save a lot of money on your utility bill.
  • Tankless water heaters last much longer: In fact, the average lifespan of a tankless water heater is twice that of a conventional unit. A heater with a tank may cease working within 12 or 15 years. The tankless unit will hold up much better for much longer.
  • A tankless water heater requires less space:Because they don’t need a massive storage tank, tankless water heaters use up much less space in your home, basement, or garage.
  • When you go tankless, you have unlimited hot water whenever you need it:With an on-demand unit, you’ll have as much hot water as you need within seconds.
  • A tankless hot water heater will allow you to run multiple showers or appliances at once:Looking to have a shower, run the dishwasher, and do a load of laundry at the same time? No problem. Tankless water heaters will allow you to do all of this and more without worrying about the hot water running out.

These are just a few of the of the advantages of tankless water heaters.

Water Heater
Water Heater

The Cons of Getting a Tankless Water Heater

Now that we’ve covered the advantages, let’s focus on some of the drawbacks. Here are a few important disadvantages of tankless water heaters.

  • They tend to be more expensive:Generally speaking, water heaters without a tank will cost you more money on the front end. Indeed, if you’re looking for a new hot water heater on a tight budget, this may not be the option for you. However, we would note that tankless water heaters can save you money over the long haul, both because of the energy savings and because of their longer shelf life.
  • Sometimes, installation is a little more complicated:Depending on your home plumbing setup and how much retrofitting is required, installing tankless water heaters can sometimes take longer and require more work. This can vary from one home to the next.
  • Tankless water heaters don’t work as well for larger homes: How many bathrooms do you have? And how many people live with you? If your home has three bathrooms or fewer, tankless water heaters work wonders. For really large homes, however, you may run into energy output problems. For really big homes with many bathrooms, multiple tankless water heaters may be required.

These are just a few disadvantages to keep in mind as you think about heaters tankless and otherwise.

Gas Boiler
worker set up central gas heating boiler at home

Making the Right Decision About Your Hot Water Heater

To recap, what are the advantages and disadvantages of a tankless water heater? And, what are some of the factors you should consider as you shop for a new unit?

  • A conventional hot water heater will last 20 years at the most. Water heaters without tanks will last considerably longer.
  • In terms of energy consumption and hot water per minute, water heaters without tanks are much more efficient.
  • However, it’s not right to say that a tankless hot water unit will never run out of water. In larger homes with many bathrooms, there can be some issues or limitations.
  • Most water heaters without tanks run on gas. Electric models are available, but they are a lot pricier.
  • Because they help you save space and make more efficient use of water, tankless models are better bets overall. However, these units may not be viable options for everyone.

As you consider the different kinds of hot water units that are available, we invite you to contact Carter’s My Plumber. We’ll evaluate your water heating needs and show you some units that we can recommend. Our plumbing experts have ample experience consulting on water heating needs, and we can also provide fast and affordable water heater installation.

Reach out to Carter’s My Plumber with any additional water heater questions or needs.

Kelson Carter

Article reviewed by:

Kelson Carter, aka, The Prince of Plumbing

Kelson is a 3rd generation Plumbing Contractor. His family business is located in Greenwood, Indiana, and provides Residential Plumbing Service to the Indianapolis Metro market.

Kelson grew up watching his grandfather and father do plumbing. After graduating high school, Kelson went to Trade School and became a Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor. He is also Certified in Backflow Prevention. He currently owns and operates Carter's My Plumber with his parents.


Schedule Your Appointment Now

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY
Happy Fourth of July from Carter's My Plumber & our patriotic goldens! Wishing our customers a safe, long weekend! 

Our offices will be closed Monday, July 4th as our staff celebrates Independence Day with their families. Call us at 317-859-9999 to get your appointment scheduled before the holiday weekend!
Starting the week off with an awesome, 5 star Google review! Way to go, Jarred! We so appreciate our loyal customers & them taking the time to give us feedback. 

Give us a call at 317-859-9999 if you have a drain that needs unclogged or a plumbing issue that needs resolved. Our technicians are here to make YOUR life EASIER!
No ruff days around here! Happy Golden Friday from two of our most loyal employees, Max & Bella. 

Call us at 317-859-9999 or visit us online at to receive GOLDEN service.
CARTER CARES! Visit our Facebook page to learn more about our CARTER CARES water heater give away program. Visit us online at if you or someone you know is in need of hot water.
Today, we're recognizing Alex's June work anniversary. Alex has been an important part of our team for 3 years! His attention to detail, pride in his work, and customer service skills are all things we truly value. We can't wait for year 4, Carters is SO lucky to have you! 

Call our office at 317-859-9999 or visit us online at to get an appointment with one of our awesome team members, they are the best in the business!
This week we are recognizing our June work anniversaries!

Everyone, meet Luke! Luke has been on our team for 1 year. His willingness to take on new roles, work ethic, and positive attitude are all qualities we are SO thankful for! This guy is our go to for drains and we cannot wait to see him expand his skill set in year 2! 

Give us a call at 317-859-9999 or visit us online at to schedule your appointment with one of our team members.
As we enter Father's Day weekend, we want to give a shoutout to our awesome technicians, who are also INCREDIBLE dads! Happy Father's Day from Carter's My Plumber!
May CARTER CARES Installation going in this morning. We are so thankful we were able to install a new hot water heater for Heather & her children! If you know of someone in need, please visit our CARTER CARES page at or give us a call at 317-859-9999!
Everyone Say Hi to Mr. Tim Holtman!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
Throwback Thursday!
Do you Recognize This Guy?
How Some of you React When You Hear our Ads.

Sing it loud and Proud!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
317-859-9999 /
One of Our Apprentices Putin’ in Work!
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!”
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!” 317-859-9999 /
Have a Great Friday!
317-859-9999 /
Carter’s My Plumber won PHCC‘s company of the year award! Peep the new decal!
317-859-9999 /
“Hot Water Today or It’s You We Pay!” 317-859-9999 /