Licensed Plumber LICENSE #CO88900054
Call For a Licensed Plumber: (317) 859-9999

Are you considering replacing the water heater in your home? Or maybe you are building a new home and debating if a tank or tankless water heater better fits your needs?

Luckily, there are a number of factors homeowners can decipher from. Here are the components of each heater!

Standard Tank Water Heater

Conventional Water Heaters:

Tank water heaters are more of the “original way” to conveniently having a surplus of hot water stored in your home. Tanks store up to 30-60 gallons of hot water and vary in size depending on how many gallons it stores. Tanks are around five feet tall so space for installation is required. But, tank style is less expensive to install versus tankless and last 10-12 years.

Conventional Efficiency and Installation: 

  • The annual cost to operate a gas tank water heater is around $245 VERSUS the annual cost to operate an electric tank water heater is around $580.
  • Tanks are less expensive to install ranging from $500-$1,000 depending on the tank size.

On-Demand Water Heaters:

Also known as “on-demand” water heaters. Tankless water heaters are mounted onto a wall and the water is heated as it passes through the pipes. Gas tankless water heaters require preventive maintenance about once a year versus none for tank style or electric tankless. Tankless heaters can last up to 20 years!

Again, there is no tank for tankless water heaters as you are paying for what you are actually using!Tankless water heater

Tankless Efficiency and Installation:

  • Tankless Gas Heaters cost around $195 annually to operate AND electric models cost around $580 annually.
  • The higher cost of electricity makes the electric tankless more costly to operate versus gas.
  • Also to consider, tankless heaters cost a little more to purchase and install. Some models range from $525-$1,150 upfront with installation ranging from $800-$1,500. Tankless water heater models vary on the basis of brand and labor components.

 

Tank or Tankless Water Heaters in Greenwood or Indianapolis. Which is Heater is Better for You?

Obviously, we all want the best product that is going to work GREAT for a LONG time for a LOW price. So, how do you decide? Here are some discussion points:

  • If you are replacing a tank heater in your home, it will likely be less to replace it with another tank heater than pay for and install a tankless heater. And the water heater installation will only take a few hours so you can get hot water in the same day.
  • If you are building a new home though, you may consider going tankless if you are willing to pay the more expensive upfront price. But look forward to your payback in savings in about 20 years.
  • Tankless heaters require way less space than tank heaters.

CALLING A PROFESSIONAL

You may have attempted these at home repairs but your toilet is still not flushing.  Here at Carter’s My Plumber, we are committed to meeting the needs of your customers.  We are licensed plumbers in Indianapolis area, knowledgeable, friendly, and will always give you a price before any work begins. Don’t hesitate to give us a call today @ 317-859-9999 or email us @ info@cartersmyplumber.com we will be happy to send a licensed professional.  We are here for you and hope you will entrust us with your plumbing needs!

Kelson Carter

Article reviewed by:

Kelson Carter, aka, The Prince of Plumbing

Kelson is a 3rd generation Plumbing Contractor. His family business is located in Greenwood, Indiana, and provides Residential Plumbing Service to the Indianapolis Metro market.

Kelson grew up watching his grandfather and father do plumbing. After graduating high school, Kelson went to Trade School and became a Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor. He is also Certified in Backflow Prevention. He currently owns and operates Carter's My Plumber with his parents.


Instagram

Schedule Your Appointment Now

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

Clocking out soon, but still keeping things flowing smoothly until then! 317-859-9999 💦 

Happy Friday!
The holidays were great… but there’s nothing like getting back to routine. We’re officially back to work and ready to tackle leaks, clogs, and everything in between. Let’s start the year strong!

317-859-9999
Keep the cold outside—NOT in your pipes! Check out our easy winter plumbing tips. ❄️💧
Merry Christmas from Carter’s My Plumber. ⛄🎄❤💦

We thank God for the opportunity to serve our community and for the customers who trust us in their homes. May this Christmas bring you peace, joy, and cherished time with loved ones!
Cousin Eddie would say it’s… full. We’ll keep your plumbing from getting there. Get on the schedule before the end of the week to avoid your celebration becoming a SITUATION.🎄🔧

www.cartersmyplumber.com
Happy 4-Year Anniversary, Tim! 👑🛠💦

Today we celebrate our service manager who leads with integrity, steadiness, and a genuine heart for both our team and our customers. Tim, your commitment and leadership have made such a difference over these four years. We’re grateful for everything you bring to Carter’s My Plumber. 

317-859-9999
Don’t let frozen pipes steal your Christmas like the Grinch! ❄️💚 

These tips will keep your home flowing.
Don’t let your pipes turn into popsicles! 🧊 
Keep cabinets open, faucets dripping, and Carters on speed dial. 

317-859-9999
Help settle the debate: What’s the best Christmas movie of all time? 🎥👇
CARTER CARES- Our monthly water heater giveaway program. 

We are grateful for the opportunity to give back to our community. Watch this video to hear from last month's recipient. ❤

If you or someone you know is in need of hot water this holiday season, visit us online at www.cartersmyplumber.com or call our office at 317-859-9999. We would love to help!
Happy 2-Year Anniversary to our comfort advisor, Mark Matthews! 🛠

Mark's positivity, willingness to help, and commitment to doing what’s right make all the difference, not just for his customers, but for everyone he works with. Thank you for all you do and for being a valued part of the Carter’s My Plumber family.
👑
If Mark's in your home this week, give him a pat on the back! He deserves it! 317-859-9999
Happy 8-Year Anniversary, Tonya! 👑

Today we’re celebrating one of the kindest voices on our team. For eight years, Tonya has been the friendly, steady support our customers count on every day.
Thank you for your dedication, patience, and heart. We’re so grateful you’re part of the Carter’s My Plumber family! 💙🔧

If you call 317-859-9999 and talk to Tonya, give her a congrats, she deserves it!
What's on your Christmas list?

 If you're like Ralphie, we've got your covered. 317-859-9999 🎄⛄❄
Found the culprit! 🌱➡️🚽 

A MASSIVE rootball clogging the sewer line. When in doubt, we scope it out! Your sewer might look fine from the outside… but underground? That’s where we come in. Call the professionals! 

317-859-9999
What's a necessity with the cold weather? HOT WATER. 

Maintenance, replacement, repair- we've got ALL things water heater covered. 💦❄🛠
www.cartersmyplumber.com
HAPPY DECEMBER 1!!!!! 🎅🏻🎁❄️🎄⛄

It's that time of year. Things get busy & the weather gets COLD. 
Call us at 317-859-9999 to make sure your plumbing isn't another thing you've got to worry about!
Happy Thanksgiving from the Carters—your trusted plumbers! May your day be full of joy, good food, and clog-free drains. 🦃🚿
🎉 Happy 3-Year Work Anniversary, Keith! 🎉

From the start, you’ve shown dedication, a great attitude, and a strong willingness to learn. Your hard work hasn’t gone unnoticed, and we’re proud to have you as part of the team. Here’s to many more successful years ahead! 👏🔧

If Keith is in your home this week, give him a pat on the back! He deserves it! 317-859-9999