Licensed Plumber LICENSE #CO88900054
Call For a Licensed Plumber: (317) 859-9999

Little do we know how easy water heaters make our lives. Can you imagine taking a cold shower everyday (if you are a shower everyday type of person). Water heaters are easily one of the most expensive system a house or building can have and when they fail, it can make life a little annoying when it comes to laundry and bathing. If you are thinking that maybe it is time to replace your home water heater.

Carter’s my Plumber provides water heater repair in Indianapolis, Carmel water heater repair, Fishers and Greenwood.

There are a couple of symptoms that you can look for before you go hot-waterless!

When You Should Replace Your Water Heater?

Remember that water heaters have an expected lifespan of about ten years before things may go south. Maybe you built the house you live in and know how old your water heater is. But, if you bought the home you can check when the last time it was serviced and installed on the water heater service sticker. This is usually located toward the top of the water heater and looks like this.

Knocking Noises

If you are hearing “knocking” noises coming from your water heater. That is a sign of sediment build-up. Sediment comes from the minerals in the water and it can harden and knock against the tank. Usually, a regular water heater flush can prevent this from happening.

Rusty or Cloudy Water

If you realize that your water has a rusty or cloudy look to it. That is a sign that either one of the two things are happening:

  • If rusty, the tank has rust on the inside and needs to be replaced. Since tanks are metal, this is bound to happen at sometime.
  • If cloudy, this is again a sign of sediment build-up.

Water Around Your Water Heater

If there is water pooling around the bottom of your tank, this is a possible sign that your tank is fractured or there is a fitting loose that causes your water heater to leak. Because metal expands when it gets hot. This can cause little fractures on the tank. Be sure to check that all fittings around the water heater are dry first before thinking it is a fracture. But, if there are fractures, this is when you should replace your water heater.

Your “Hot Water” is Cold

Obviously, if you are attempting to get hot water from the sink and it is “luke warm” or simply cold. There could be something wrong with the thermostat or the heating element within your water heater.

water pressure

Call a Professional

If you are having issues with your water heater and are wondering when you should replace your water heater. Give Carter’s My Plumber, we are committed to meeting the needs of our customers.  We are knowledgeable, friendly, and will always give you a price before any work begins. Don’t hesitate to give us a call today @ 317-859-9999 or email us @ info@cartersmyplumber.com we will be happy to send a licensed professional.  We are here for you and hope you will entrust us with your plumbing needs!

Kelson Carter

Article reviewed by:

Kelson Carter, aka, The Prince of Plumbing

Kelson is a 3rd generation Plumbing Contractor. His family business is located in Greenwood, Indiana, and provides Residential Plumbing Service to the Indianapolis Metro market.

Kelson grew up watching his grandfather and father do plumbing. After graduating high school, Kelson went to Trade School and became a Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor. He is also Certified in Backflow Prevention. He currently owns and operates Carter's My Plumber with his parents.


Instagram

Schedule Your Appointment Now

  • MM slash DD slash YYYY

"Threading pipe isn’t just about making the connection — it’s about making it last. 🛠️ Properly threaded pipes mean leak‑free, secure plumbing systems that stand the test of time. Trust the pros to get it right the first time!

317-859-9999
Happy 4 Year Work Anniversary to Elijah, one of our LICENSED PLUMBERS! 💪🛠💦

4 years have flown with you on Team Carter. This guy works hard, is a true tradesman & teammate, and he's an all around great GUY. He's an awesome example for the younger generation of plumbers and we're thankful for all he does! We can't wait to see what the future holds for you in the trades, we know it's bright!

If Elijah is in your home this week, give him a big congrats! He deserves it! 317-859-9999 ⭐👑
Happy 6 Year Work Anniversary to our dispatcher, Trent! 💪🛠⭐

What would we do without this guy? He keeps our team moving (& laughing) all day, everyday! He's hardworking, positive, and just a joy to be around. We are so grateful for all he does for Carter's My Plumber and can't wait for what is to come! 👑

If you call the office this week and talk to Trent, give him a big congrats! He deserves it! 317-859-9999
Happy Fourth of July from Carter's My Plumber! Offices are closed today. We'll be back at it on Monday! 🇺🇸🎇💪
It's JULY! Let freedom & water flow. Start the month off smooth with CARTERS- you won't regret it.
 
317-859-9999 💦🎇🇺🇸
Happy 3 Year Work Anniversary to our excavation team leader, Ryder!! 💪🛠👑

This guy is always up for a challenge, steps up when it's needed, and works hard! He's dependable, responsible, and an all around GOOD guy! 3 years have flown! We are so grateful for all you do, Ryder! 

If Ryder is in your yard this week, give him a pat on the back. He deserves all of the recognition! 317-859-9999 ⭐
Hard water? It's not a hard decision, you need to go soft. 

Water softeners mean cleaner dishes, softer laundry, and longer lasting appliances. Install with us and feel the difference with every drop! 317-859-9999 🛠💦
Happy 4 Year Work Anniversary to one of our plumbers, Luke! 🛠

This year you finished school, continued to exemplify HARD work, and truly became a leader on the team! 4 years have flown by with you on our team and we can't wait to see what your future holds. His future is BRIGHT and we're so grateful for all you do. 

If Luke is in your home this week, know you're in the best hands! Give him a pat on the back- he deserves it. 317-859-9999 💪💦
Water where it's not supposed to be? You better have one of these trucks in your drive 💦

www.cartersmyplumber.com
Our favorite kind of fan mail, meet Ziva! 

 "Hot Water Today or Its You We Pay...." 💦
Holiday weekend....you hosting? Give us a call to make sure that pesky, plumbing problem doesn't stand in the way of you & a relaxing, long weekend. Limited spots available! 💦

317-859-9999
3/4 of our 2025 Mechanical Skills Graduates! 💦⭐💪

Another shout out to Luke, Jarred, and Elijah for their amazing accomplishment (missing Josh!). We are so PROUD of these guys. 

#CartersMyPlumber
You'd never know they left the job covered in dirt by the smiles. 😀💪

A good attitude & a good teammate go a long way. HAPPY FRIDAY
www.cartersmyplumber.com
Hey, YOU! Check your water heater & see if you're due for a flush soon- you'll be hearing from us.....

Maintenance is KEY when it comes to the effectiveness and longevity of your water heater. Keep up with it so it can keep up with YOU- 317-859-9999 💦
We made it to the weekend, will your drains? Visit us online to explore our jetting options- your lines don't stand a chance! 💦💪

317-859-9999
Nothing better than seeing one of these trucks pull up in your driveway. Visit us online to look at our thousands of ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ reviews! We'd love to make Carter's YOUR plumber. 

317-859-9999
Having water heater issues? Want a FREE estimate to see what a plumbing repair or replacement would look like? Call us, we got it
! 
317-859-9999
Happy 3 Year Work Anniversary to our water/sewer team leader, Matt! 💦

This guy is a team player, skilled in the trade, dedicated to our customers, and passionate about mentoring the next generation of tradesmen! 3 years have flown & we're excited for continued growth in the years to come! 💪⭐👑🛠

If Matt is at your home this week, give him a big pat on the back, he deserves it! Thanks for all you do, Matt! 317-859-9999